Halt the Interrogation!

Assertion of your 5th and 6th Amendment rights is difficult.  This is the right to remain silent (not self-incriminate, or the 5th) and the right to counsel (the 6th).  The reason it’s hard to assert these rights is that you’re not supposed to.

I’m conflicted about all this.  I’ve run into police stations, waived my card and Cook County ID around and asked to see my client, where I tell them, immediately, to shut the hell up.  I also tell the detectives assigned to their case that my client is shutting the hell up and that he has a lawyer.

However, as a law abiding citizen, and as someone who actually does want the police to catch criminals, assertion of these rights is anathema to the crime solving process.  You have no idea how many crimes are sealed with a confession.

Now, a confession alone cannot convict you.  This is the theory of corpus delicti and it basically holds that absent any other sign of a crime, a confession alone should not convict anyone.  This goes back to the Star Chamber in England where confessions were elicited by a judicial system with no oversight.  As a result, aristocrats and enemies of the crown admitted to treason and acts of subversion, without any other evidence being presented besides the aristocrats own (forced) confession.

Today, we find that sort of behavior reprehensible.  Yet, plenty of convictions move forward where nearly the only evidence is just the confession.  This is not appropriate…and in almost all cases it’s because the defendant did not clearly assert (or more likely, was completely unaware of) their right to remain silent or to retain counsel.

Sure, sure, we read all defendants the Miranda warning…but do they understand it?  They almost always say the do, but if you were to explain to a person who was just arrested, sitting in a police interrogation room what their rights are in plain English, they’d be surprised.  Or at least enlightened.  Of course, it’s not the police’s job to give criminal defendant’s a civics lesson, just read their rights off a card and proceed like nothing happened.

So why am I conflicted?  Because I want the police to catch killers, molesters, thieves and dealers.  My job is to be a passionate advocate and defend your rights to their fullest extent.  But that doesn’t mean I want you to get away with murder.

My favorite professor in law school was a former appellate public defender in Illinois, a JAG lawyer, and now one of the premier criminal defense lawyers in Wisconsin.  His line to us the first day of Evidence was “The guilty go to prison.”  He didn’t mean that our job was futile, he just meant that evidence and the truth, frequently has a way of working itself out.  As it should be.


3 responses to “Halt the Interrogation!

  1. You say that you don’t want to help us get away with murder, but if we’re one of your clients, you will, right?

    (Within the rules, of course.)

    I wouldn’t normally ask the question, but since you mentioned that you feel conflicted, I’m wondering what it is about criminal defense that makes you do it despite that fact that you are uncomfortable helping people get away with crimes. In other words…how can you defend those people?

  2. chicagocrimelaw

    Windy –

    I can’t help anyone “get away with murder.” No lawyer can, unless they actually break the law. No, what I do is I defend your rights, and I make sure that the other side doesn’t cheat. That’s not the same as helping you get away with murder.

    My view is that a prosecutor or police officer who breaks the law to convict you is a criminal. And criminals convicting criminals is frontier justice. You might as well get a posse and go around shooting wrong doers. That’s where I come in, I’m the civilizing force that makes sure we’re all playing the same game.

    It’s not a matter of whether you think you should “get away” with murder, it’s whether the other side isn’t getting away with breaking the law to convict you.

  3. “The guilty go to prison.”
    Not all of them by any means – and they share it all too often with the innocent.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s